I wouldn't consider a personal opinion on a professional practitioner on a public forum of any constructive use. Destructive, perhaps yes, for their reputation.
Quite surprised at a moderator supporting the idea too.

I would go by instinct pick a doc try a visit and if you aren't happy pick another at random... until you are happy. No other way.

No doctor/dentist/baker/shoemaker would be still in biz if nobody liked them, surely?