Your profile gives us nothing to go on so we've very little idea what your interests are and what way of life you lead.
This probably isn't very helpful and you've perhaps done all these things anyway but I'll tell you what I'd do.
I'd 'case the joint' to give myself a feeling for the places under consideration. I'd look at the homepages as this gives one quite a fair idea of what goes on (or doesn't go on - as the case may be). Look at the information on various clubs and organisations. Check the date on the various pages!
I'd snoop round the places (on foot), go into the shops, ask for things there and see how folk react.
What is public transport like? Even if you normally travel by car, someone, sometime, who doesn't have a car might want to visit you!
I loved living in a (very) small village for a limited time but 'lights out' at six in the evening is not everyone's cup of tea.