4) Na ma tutgai betg là! ( Don't touch me there! )
Cheers,
Nick
Might be more useful than you imagine. My uncle, who was a Romansh speaker from the Grisons, emigrated to the USA with one of his brothers as a young man. At the end of his life he was executive head of room service at the Plaza in New York.
Many, many others from his region emigrated to work in the hotel and restaurant trade. You might find some still in a beach resort somewhere.
But then Romansh, like so many other minor languages of Europe, has been in decline for decades. It has 35,000 fluent speakers. Its survival is probably dependant on governmental subsidy. http://www.centerladin.ch/85+M52087573ab0.0.html
And even there is economic reality: http://uniset.ca/naty/hebdo_allemand.htm
My uncle married another Swiss but they spoke only English to their daughter, more's the pity.
Location: Sarganserland / NW Lower Peninsula of NE US Midwest
Posts: 1,993
Groaned at 21 Times in 18 Posts
Thanked 2,883 Times in 1,092 Posts
Re: Romansh - Useless Phrases
Please note that there are five main Romansh dialects in Switzerland alone and a few more in Southern Tyrol. They differ so much that, for instance, people from the lower Engadine have a hard time understanding a radio annoucer from the Surselva (Anterior Rhine Valley), less than 60 kilometers apart, as the crow flies.
I do not even know what kind of dialect those extremely useful sentences are. They definitely can't be used in the Engadine. Maybe it's Rumantsch Grischun, the synthetic lingua franca introduced in the 'eighties to enable the Grisons and the Federation to print laws that can be read by all native Romansh speakers.
The following 5 users would like to thank Captain Greybeard for this useful post:
Please note that there are five main Romansh dialects in Switzerland alone and a few more in Southern Tyrol. They differ so much that, for instance, people from the lower Engadine have a hard time understanding a radio annoucer from the Surselva (Anterior Rhine Valley), less than 60 kilometers apart, as the crow flies.
I do not even know what kind of dialect those extremely useful sentences are. They definitely can't be used in the Engadine. Maybe it's Rumantsch Grischun, the synthetic lingua franca introduced in the 'eighties to enable the Grisons and the Federation to print laws that can be read by all native Romansh speakers.
Being able to ask where the beach is in Romansh seems indeed as useful as enquiring about the location of the nearest ski resort in the middle of the Sahara desert. I hope -but I acknowledge this might be wishful thinking- that situations where phrase n°4 would be used are equally rare.
This user would like to thank Rustygraben for this useful post:
Simon, if you spoke that "stupid language," you'd soon realize that its 35,000 to 45,000 native speakers share a much richer and far more active literary scene than Swiss German with several million native speakers.
The following 2 users would like to thank Captain Greybeard for this useful post:
You obviousely don't have the slightest clue what you are talking about. If you had lived in the Romansh speaking area of Switzerland for a long time as I did, you would... The Romansh language is part of the Swiss culture, if it would be eradicated, an important part of our culture would die. Viva il rumantsch!
The following 2 users would like to thank zürihegel for this useful post:
Simon, if you spoke that "stupid language," you'd soon realize that its 35,000 to 45,000 native speakers share a much richer and far more active literary scene than Swiss German with several million native speakers.
Yeah ok, but then just get on with it. If you like the language that much then surely all those millions spent on that heart bypass are wasted anyway, because people won't let it die ? I must admit though that I just dislike the language with a passion because I had to watch "Sandmändli" in Rumantsch when I was 4. Appreciate your groans, but don't take it too seriously please.
Record a few tapes with the language and then let it die in peace.
Yeah ok, but then just get on with it. If you like the language that much then surely all those millions spent on that heart bypass are wasted anyway, because people won't let it die ? I must admit though that I just dislike the language with a passion because I had to watch "Sandmändli" in Rumantsch when I was 4. Appreciate your groans, but don't take it too seriously please.
Record a few tapes with the language and then let it die in peace.
This user would like to thank Sada for this useful post: