 | | | 
14.02.2009, 18:19
| Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Bāle
Posts: 257
Groaned at 7 Times in 6 Posts
Thanked 35 Times in 16 Posts
| | Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
Hi
I was checking for car insurance premium at comparis.ch for my car model Grand Cherokee. I found that if I change just one field nationality from India to France then I pay approx. 1000 CHF less (or approx. 50% of what I would pay if the nationality field was set to India). By the way, I hold a swiss driving licence.
Is this normal? anybody in EF fprum have similar experiences?
Ashish
| 
14.02.2009, 18:46
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Is this normal? | | | | | Yes, certain nationalities have fallen into high risk groups. Read recently the highest risk group of drivers are those of former Yugoslav nationality. Just for fun I checked the price on Comparis to insure an 18 year old with a new M3 BMW worth over 100,000.-chf. of Serb and USA citizenship. The Serb had a premium of over 10,000.-chf per year where as the American example would have paid around 5,400.-chf per year on the same car.
| 
14.02.2009, 21:15
| Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Bāle
Posts: 257
Groaned at 7 Times in 6 Posts
Thanked 35 Times in 16 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality The part of the premium (Partial CASCO) that applies to damages / incidents caused by environment / animals / third party related also increases by 2 fold (for my car specs) based on the nationality! This is ridiculous. I asked comparis.ch and the insurance agency directly. Comparis.ch didn't respond and the agency gave me a vague unrelated reply. In France, where I lived for so many years ... at least in paper, the laws of the land applied uniformly to all the residents in its soil. Ashish. | 
15.02.2009, 22:13
| Banned | | Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Basel
Posts: 251
Groaned at 23 Times in 11 Posts
Thanked 99 Times in 65 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
.....................................
Last edited by ElieDeLeuze; 08.07.2009 at 18:27.
| 
15.02.2009, 22:32
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Zürich
Posts: 4,521
Groaned at 18 Times in 16 Posts
Thanked 2,208 Times in 1,248 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Swiss companies seem to blindly believe in statistics rather than antidiscrimination laws or even common sense applied to statistics. Governemnt doesn't care. No petition for a referendum. So it stays. | | | | | While I admit it's not entirely the same, do you think that bonuses for accident-free drivers and higher rates for those who repeatedly have accidents also is blind trust in statistics?
| This user would like to thank Nathu for this useful post: | | 
15.02.2009, 22:34
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: DK - previously Zug
Posts: 3,323
Groaned at 168 Times in 122 Posts
Thanked 6,710 Times in 2,240 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: |  | | | Swiss companies seem to blindly believe in statistics rather than antidiscrimination laws or even common sense applied to statistics. | | | | | Isn't the whole game of insurance about discrimination by dividing people up into statistics?
I would guess that this is unlikely to change any time soon; the Swiss government sort of supports it in that drivers licenses from some countries are considered valid (and can thus be exchanged for a Swiss one) whereas licenses from other countries are ignored, forcing people to go through complete drivers examinations and such.
| 
16.02.2009, 03:16
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | In France, where I lived for so many years ... at least in paper, the laws of the land applied uniformly to all the residents in its soil.
| | | | | Is that really the case ? Think about what a young driver pays compared to an older person, or what a male pays compared to a female, even with the same track record.
| This user would like to thank for this useful post: | | 
16.02.2009, 12:11
| Forum Legend | | Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Ticino
Posts: 3,170
Groaned at 98 Times in 68 Posts
Thanked 4,212 Times in 1,678 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
If I am not mistaken the canton you live in also has a bearing. IIRC people with VS plates are most likely to have an RTA in Switzerland.
Also, health insurance is also more expensive in some cantons than others.
Insurance is all about statistics...in some cases that includes the issue of nationalities. Unfortunate? Yes. Discriminatory? Strictly speaking yes. Wrong? No...because that is the nature of insurance. People with a higher likelihood of filing a claim pay more. Fine by me.
| This user would like to thank Snoopy for this useful post: | | 
16.02.2009, 13:27
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Zurich
Posts: 12,361
Groaned at 337 Times in 273 Posts
Thanked 26,263 Times in 11,000 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Hi
I was checking for car insurance premium at comparis.ch for my car model Grand Cherokee. I found that if I change just one field nationality from India to France then I pay approx. 1000 CHF less (or approx. 50% of what I would pay if the nationality field was set to India). By the way, I hold a swiss driving licence.
Is this normal? anybody in EF fprum have similar experiences?
Ashish | | | | | My sister spent a year working in India. She was pulled out of traffic once by a police officer for breaking some minor rule, which everybody without exception was breaking, but she was singled out because she was an expat.
When she complained to the police officer that this was discrimination, he agreed, but said that's the way things are and that he was specifically instructed to watch for the expats. When she showed him her residency, proving that she was officially resident in India and employed by an Indian company, the policeman said that in that case she needn't pay the fine.
| This user would like to thank amogles for this useful post: | | 
16.02.2009, 14:36
| Forum Legend | | Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Geneva
Posts: 5,510
Groaned at 123 Times in 108 Posts
Thanked 3,297 Times in 1,737 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | |
I would guess that this is unlikely to change any time soon; the Swiss government sort of supports it in that drivers licenses from some countries are considered valid (and can thus be exchanged for a Swiss one) whereas licenses from other countries are ignored, forcing people to go through complete drivers examinations and such. | | | | | Which, if you've ever seen a philippino driver's exam, is not all bad.
| 
16.02.2009, 14:41
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: DK - previously Zug
Posts: 3,323
Groaned at 168 Times in 122 Posts
Thanked 6,710 Times in 2,240 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Which, if you've ever seen a philippino driver's exam, is not all bad. | | | | | I was trying very hard to word my post such that there no signs of approval or disapproval of the policy. :-)
| 
16.02.2009, 18:56
| Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Bāle
Posts: 257
Groaned at 7 Times in 6 Posts
Thanked 35 Times in 16 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
To clarify, what I meant was young or old driver in France have same set of rules, irrespective of their nationality.
Once again, my intention was to highlight the difference, which in my personal opinion was unfair practice. I'm not interested in nailing any country or people. I hope one day the new generation of Swiss law makers will make this difference a thing of the past.
Ashish. | Quote: | |  | | | Is that really the case ? Think about what a young driver pays compared to an older person, or what a male pays compared to a female, even with the same track record. | | | | | | 
16.02.2009, 20:09
|  | Member | | Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Brussels, Belgium
Posts: 216
Groaned at 3 Times in 3 Posts
Thanked 103 Times in 54 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Which, if you've ever seen a philippino driver's exam, is not all bad. | | | | | Seen the Top Gear Vietnam special? | 
16.02.2009, 20:33
| Banned | | Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Basel
Posts: 251
Groaned at 23 Times in 11 Posts
Thanked 99 Times in 65 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
............................................
Last edited by ElieDeLeuze; 08.07.2009 at 18:27.
| 
02.02.2011, 16:49
| Forum Veteran | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Zurich
Posts: 1,751
Groaned at 9 Times in 7 Posts
Thanked 1,285 Times in 703 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
Ashish, I was wondering if you got this sorted out?
I was on the phone yesterday with my insurance co. about buying a car and told them that I have a Swiss licence and that I passed my drivers exam in the UK 18 years ago and switched to the Swiss one some 10 years ago.
Today, they received my documents and said that seeing as my nationality is not UK nor Swiss and non-EU, the insurance will cost Fr.600 more. Wtf?
| 
02.02.2011, 17:07
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
Insurance costs are based on statistics. You'll find that women pay less than men too.
Car insurance is insuring a risk. Having a red passport to insure against dropped my premium.
You want to speak to someone who's done underwriting in insurance and potentially reinsurance to understand your dilemma | 
02.02.2011, 17:18
| Forum Veteran | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Zurich
Posts: 1,751
Groaned at 9 Times in 7 Posts
Thanked 1,285 Times in 703 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Insurance costs are based on statistics. You'll find that women pay less than men too.
Car insurance is insuring a risk. Having a red passport to insure against dropped my premium.
You want to speak to someone who's done underwriting in insurance and potentially reinsurance to understand your dilemma  | | | | | I understand that it is all statistics, but do all the companies interpret everything by the book or what? I mean, I learnt how to drive in the UK, passed my test in the UK, but simply because my passport is not a UK passport, I get penalized.
What if the situation is the other way round - say I have a UK passport, but passed my drivers test in a non-EU country. If my driving skill is based on my passport and not where I got my licence, would they charge me less?
| 
02.02.2011, 17:23
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | I understand that it is all statistics, but do all the companies interpret everything by the book or what? I mean, I learnt how to drive in the UK, passed my test in the UK, but simply because my passport is not a UK passport, I get penalized.
What if the situation is the other way round - say I have a UK passport, but passed my drivers test in a non-EU country. If my driving skill is based on my passport and not where I got my licence, would they charge me less? | | | | | I hear you but if you had GB nationality and a licence from some banana republic, you'd be happy right now.
Have you spoken to a person yet? I have a contact at Zurich who will maybe help you around issues like this as he's a human - PM me if interested.
| This user would like to thank for this useful post: | | 
02.02.2011, 17:24
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: CH
Posts: 3,200
Groaned at 86 Times in 70 Posts
Thanked 5,788 Times in 2,254 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality
In insurance you're guilty until proven to be innocent. You pay for belonging to a certain group of risk (gender, age, profession, nationality etc....). I find it also disgusting. I know Axa-Winterthur is using nationality to evaluate risk but not all insurances do it. I reduced my premium by changing to Helvetia.
| This user would like to thank MrVertigo for this useful post: | | 
02.02.2011, 17:38
|  | Senior Member | | Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Brutten
Posts: 356
Groaned at 7 Times in 4 Posts
Thanked 379 Times in 174 Posts
| | Re: Car Insurance Premium function of Nationality | Quote: | |  | | | Seen the Top Gear Vietnam special?  | | | | | It was funny...a strainer for a helmet, that doesn't even make a decent "brain bucket" as it will all seep out throught the holes. |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | | Thread Tools | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT +2. The time now is 14:24. | |