English Forum Switzerland

English Forum Switzerland (https://www.englishforum.ch/forum.php)
-   Daily life (https://www.englishforum.ch/daily-life/)
-   -   I got so touched today by a great human reaction (https://www.englishforum.ch/daily-life/118092-i-got-so-touched-today-great-human-reaction.html)

Mowvich 30.06.2011 13:18

I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
I were earlier in the bus when the ticket inspectors came on the bus, there were a woman behind me with her little daughter, she had abo for the daughter but no ticket for herself, the inspector took her ID and went to the other inspector to bring this machine to issue a bill, the woman had few tears in her eyes, the inspector came back and gave her back her ID and said "I can be human sometimes" and the other inspector got a chocolate from his pocket and gave it to the girl, seriously that was the most awesome reaction i ever seen in CH since i arrived here 6 years ago that i really wanted to thank the inspectors for giving up on the bureaucracy and being human for once :o

All respect for these 2 inspectors who really went beyond their duty and been so human, they made everyone's day on the bus i guess :)

Treverus 30.06.2011 13:25

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

They guys have the job to make sure that a few people aren't stealing from the community. This lady apparently did and I think she should be fined. I find the controllers a bit too harsh on many things - people who have abos, can proof their ID and simply forgot them on them... or people who bought their mobile phone ticket a second after the train left the station. But somebody who simply doesn't have one should be fined, no matter if they have tears in their eyes or not.

In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".

Carlos R 30.06.2011 13:28

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".

Grown men cry too, you know...

http://www.open-tennis.com/images/te...e/image011.jpg

:p

Mowvich 30.06.2011 13:29

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
First: The inspector was actually a woman not a guy

Second: I don't care at all about 80 CHF less in a rich govt income as much as i really care much more for smile on a human beings face.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

They guys have the job to make sure that a few people aren't stealing from the community. This lady apparently did and I think she should be fined. I find the controllers a bit too harsh on many things - people who have abos, can proof their ID and simply forgot them on them... or people who bought their mobile phone ticket a second after the train left the station. But somebody who simply doesn't have one should be fined, no matter if they have tears in their eyes or not.

In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".


Guest 30.06.2011 13:33

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

They guys have the job to make sure that a few people aren't stealing from the community. This lady apparently did and I think she should be fined. I find the controllers a bit too harsh on many things - people who have abos, can proof their ID and simply forgot them on them... or people who bought their mobile phone ticket a second after the train left the station. But somebody who simply doesn't have one should be fined, no matter if they have tears in their eyes or not.

In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".

Geezus why so angry dude ?

Lejoker 30.06.2011 13:36

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
The fact of the matter is that the woman broke the law; she had no ticket.
I would sympathize with her had she lost it or bought the wrong one...but getting on the bus & not buying the ticket is a way of cheating the system & cheating those who actually pay. It is not fair.

Carlos R 30.06.2011 13:37

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mowvich (Post 1246109)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".

First: The inspector was actually a woman not a guy

Second: I don't care at all about 80 CHF less in a rich govt income as much as i really care much more for smile on a human beings face.

You see - and Trev isn't even Swiss. Just imagine how pissed a Swiss person would have been about the system's failure if they'd witnessed it.

PaddyG 30.06.2011 13:37

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Angela-74 (Post 1246119)
Geezus why so angry dude ?

He was on the same bus, didn't have a ticket and was fined for it ;)

Carlos R 30.06.2011 13:37

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lejoker (Post 1246122)
The fact of the matter is that the woman broke the law; she had no ticket.
I would sympathize with her had she lost it or bought the wrong one...but getting on the bus & not buying the ticket is a way of cheating the system & cheating those who actually pay. It is not fair.

So you've never made a mistake in your life then?

Congrats. You're perfect, I wish I was like you.

PaddyG 30.06.2011 13:38

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos R (Post 1246106)

Is that from yesterday? Oh it can't be, he's holding the trophy :D

Mowvich 30.06.2011 13:41

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lejoker (Post 1246122)
The fact of the matter is that the woman broke the law; she had no ticket.
I would sympathize with her had she lost it or bought the wrong one...but getting on the bus & not buying the ticket is a way of cheating the system & cheating those who actually pay. It is not fair.

So many things in todays world are not fair, there's bankers who are stealing us everyday around the globe and it's not fair, there's armies going to wars killing people and it's not fair, there's corrupt politicians telling us what to do and what not to do and it's not fair, a true smile on a human being's face is much more fair than all of the above and if it bothers any of you i would be happily going to pay the 80 chf she had to pay and i would feel so honored doing

Treverus 30.06.2011 13:41

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Angela-74 (Post 1246119)
Geezus why so angry dude ?

I am not angry. I just don't think this is super behaviour. There are plenty of really questionable rules in Switzerland and every time I see a cop/any civil servant turn a blind eye when he agrees that the bureaucracy is rubbish - I applaud.

I am not angry about people not buying tickets either - they take the risk getting caught and steal from the community. What I do not get is people being happy about them not getting what they deserve. You take a risk to get an unfair advantage and well, you weren't lucky. Same as speeding or pretty much any other offense.
Crying about getting caught is nothing short of pathetic. And so is a controller who does turn a blind eye to people without tickets. He does not get paid to only fine people he doesn't like.

john h 30.06.2011 13:43

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

They guys have the job to make sure that a few people aren't stealing from the community. This lady apparently did and I think she should be fined. I find the controllers a bit too harsh on many things - people who have abos, can proof their ID and simply forgot them on them... or people who bought their mobile phone ticket a second after the train left the station. But somebody who simply doesn't have one should be fined, no matter if they have tears in their eyes or not.

In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".

With an attitude like that, I don't expect many people are kind to you!
In a world that has grime, crime and slime everyday, things like that are what gives everyone hope.

Mowvich 30.06.2011 13:44

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
You never know what situation this person is in and why they didn't buy a ticket, but if you were there, you would have understood very well that this was a perfect human to human reaction.

Do not blindly judge cause the system tells you so, use your brain and instinct instead to deal with fellow humans

Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246132)
I am not angry. I just don't think this is super behaviour. There are plenty of really questionable rules in Switzerland and every time I see a cop/any civil servant turn a blind eye when he agrees that the bureaucracy is rubbish - I applaud.

I am not angry about people not buying tickets either - they take the risk getting caught and steal from the community. What I do not get is people being happy about them not getting what they deserve. You take a risk to get an unfair advantage and well, you weren't lucky. Same as speeding or pretty much any other offense.
Crying about getting caught is nothing short of pathetic. And so is a controller who does turn a blind eye to people without tickets. He does not get paid to only fine people he doesn't like.


TidakApa 30.06.2011 13:44

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

They guys have the job to make sure that a few people aren't stealing from the community. This lady apparently did and I think she should be fined. I find the controllers a bit too harsh on many things - people who have abos, can proof their ID and simply forgot them on them... or people who bought their mobile phone ticket a second after the train left the station. But somebody who simply doesn't have one should be fined, no matter if they have tears in their eyes or not.

In my opinion was this not great but wrong behaviour. Do you think he would have done the same to a guy? If not, it was only chauvinistic, but not "human".


........ Having a bad day Treverus?

Seems like you are fighting an inner desire to be a "Ticket Inspector" for the ZVV

go on..... apply for a job !!!

Carlos R 30.06.2011 13:44

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246132)
I am not angry about people not buying tickets either - they take the risk getting caught and steal from the community. What I do not get is people being happy about them not getting what they deserve. You take a risk to get an unfair advantage and well, you weren't lucky. Same as speeding or pretty much any other offense.
Crying about getting caught is nothing short of pathetic. And so is a controller who does turn a blind eye to people without tickets. He does not get paid to only fine people he doesn't like.

You, know, Trev, I kinda agree with you... but... people do make mistakes. I've jumped on a tram without my tram pass, having left it at home and only realised once I've got home.

People do make mistakes, and I can understand a mother with a child being tired - aka emotional - during the morning commute and forgetting to buy the ticket.

We don't actually know that the person knowingly tried to ticket dodge.

Mowvich 30.06.2011 13:46

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by john h (Post 1246136)
With an attitude like that, I don't expect many people are kind to you!
In a world that has grime, crime and slime everyday, things like that are what gives everyone hope.

That is exactly my point, i saw hope in humans within a totally controlled system and this was so beautiful :o

Jordan Baker 30.06.2011 13:48

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Treverus (Post 1246103)
Why was that a great reaction? Even without a job are you able to afford your public transport ticket here... the social security is great.

You never know the circumstances...

Additionally, I guess when you're working as ticket inspector you have developed a pretty good sensitivity, if it'll be alright to make an exception.

nickatbasel 30.06.2011 13:50

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Treverus is quite right. These people who "forget" to pay their bus fares are just playing the system. I think anyone caught on public transport without a valid ticket should be kicked out of the country. And then there's those who bring their library books back late. In the village stocks I say.

And the other day, I saw one pillock in a car driving at 51km/h when it was clearly signposted 50!

It just gets worse and Switzerland is on such a downward spiral that in 2 years time it will be just like Basingstoke!

Cheers,
Nick

Treverus 30.06.2011 13:51

Re: I got so touched today by a great human reaction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by billhardie (Post 1246139)
........ Having a bad day Treverus?

No, I really really don't have a bad day. I seriously believe what I posted above. And I don't care if some hippies groan at me for it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos R (Post 1246140)
You, know, Trev, I kinda agree with you... but... people do make mistakes.

Sure. I made many mistakes in my life. And when I got caught... I paid. Simple.

I am not "pro laws" or anything. I simply believe in Kant and his take on self awareness. In short that people are responsible for their actions. If you make a mistake, pay for it. If you did it on purpose (and honestly, how many people really FORGET that you need a ticket..?), you took your chance and lost. Nothing to cry either.

And to be clear again: No, I don't know what situation the woman was in. This being Switzerland I am aware what benefits even the poorest here live on - yes, they don't need to dodge the fare. Yes, the 80 bucks might sting a person on the dough - rightfully so.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 10:40.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0