English Forum Switzerland

English Forum Switzerland (https://www.englishforum.ch/forum.php)
-   Daily life (https://www.englishforum.ch/daily-life/)
-   -   Star Wars movie for 8 y.o? (https://www.englishforum.ch/daily-life/278203-star-wars-movie-8-y-o.html)

Mindset 15.12.2017 14:52

Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Hi all
Tried to search the forum, but did not find a definite answer.
Id like to take my 8 y.o. to the new Star Wars movie. The age rating for the film is 14/12, meaning kids as of 12 y.o. are allowed in if accompanied by an adult. At the same time, I believe that SW is fine for the age of 8.
Would cinema personnel refuse entry in this case? Did anyone have an experience bringing kids to the movies that had higher age rating in ZH cinemas?
Thanks in advance!

bigblue2 15.12.2017 15:00

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
I really don't think an 8yr old will enjoy the film, its a bit more adult orientated then the last one, and in places a lot more violent.

I got the impression disney realised they aren't making SW films for kids anymore ;)

Guest 15.12.2017 15:12

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
If they suspect the kid is to young they might ask for proof of age and then by law are demanded to refuse your kid entry.

You might be in luck that nobody asks or checks, you might be in bad luck and end up buying tickets for a nice cartoon (and download the movie at home)

swisspea 15.12.2017 15:25

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Go see it first, then decide whether to take your kid...

As said, the movies are getting more 'confronting' as we go along...

Has he seen all the others ?

Troublawesome 16.12.2017 13:27

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Just saw it yesterday, Disney completely destroyed Star Wars. It;s definitely made for kids now, looked more like comedy than action movie.

Nothing offensive either, imo it's fine for a 8yo

Ace1 16.12.2017 14:23

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Troublawesome (Post 2886557)
Just saw it yesterday, Disney completely destroyed Star Wars. It;s definitely made for kids now, looked more like comedy than action movie.

So nothing's changed then?

I would read the 14/12 guidance as suggesting a maximum age limit, not a minimum.

DantesDame 16.12.2017 17:45

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Troublawesome (Post 2886557)
Just saw it yesterday, Disney completely destroyed Star Wars. It;s definitely made for kids now, looked more like comedy than action movie.

Nothing offensive either, imo it's fine for a 8yo

We just came back from the theater - that movie is a hot mess and I wouldn't recommend ANYONE going to see it, regardless of the age :o

Still, kids like this kind of stuff, and from what I know of 8 year olds (almost nothing), I didn't see anything dreadfully violent. I mean, other than the typical hacking and slicing that comes with light sabres, or course.

Daff 16.12.2017 18:48

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DantesDame (Post 2886635)
We just came back from the theater - that movie is a hot mess and I wouldn't recommend ANYONE going to see it, regardless of the age :o

Still, kids like this kind of stuff, and from what I know of 8 year olds (almost nothing), I didn't see anything dreadfully violent. I mean, other than the typical hacking and slicing that comes with light sabres, or course.

Oh no! My husband and I drew straws on which one of us was going to take our 11 year old. I drew the short straw. Now I'm looking forward to it even less *sigh*. The things we do for our kids ...

Guest 16.12.2017 19:26

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Daff (Post 2886656)
Oh no! My husband and I drew straws on which one of us was going to take our 11 year old. I drew the short straw. Now I'm looking forward to it even less *sigh*. The things we do for our kids ...

Just see it, there are people who don't like it, there are people who love it. Critics and reviews give it good grades. Only one way to find out if you like it.

aSwissInTheUS 16.12.2017 20:54

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mindset (Post 2886288)
Hi all
Tried to search the forum, but did not find a definite answer.
Id like to take my 8 y.o. to the new Star Wars movie. The age rating for the film is 14/12, meaning kids as of 12 y.o. are allowed in if accompanied by an adult. At the same time, I believe that SW is fine for the age of 8.
Would cinema personnel refuse entry in this case? Did anyone have an experience bringing kids to the movies that had higher age rating in ZH cinemas?

Age ratings are a cantonal thing. For example in ZG it is 9 and SG 12/10.
The cinema personal may prevent entry in case the age gap is to obvious.
In the worst case the police makes checks at the entrance :eek: Seen this only once when my dad brought my sister and me in a 16 movie. They asked how old we were and he said the right age and we just agreed :cool:

slammer 16.12.2017 21:19

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Just went and watched it. My verdict... Yes your eight year old can view it, if he or she is not coddled in cotton wool or is called Tarquin. In my opinion J.J. Abrams should never have been allowed to do either the starwars or the startrek stuff, perhaps in hell he will have to do documentaries, something like the life and death of lichen. If that is what passes for world cinema these days then ok, but I watched the original in 1977 so my expectations are quite high.

Wisconsinite 17.12.2017 00:41

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Don't know what you all are complaining about. I thought it was best of the new Star Wars movies and way better than Force Awakens.

blackbird 17.12.2017 05:30

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
I like the new star wars pretty much, but when this is your first star wars movie, it will be a struggle to follow the story.
The film in my opinion is not for a 8 year old kid, the kid should be at least 12 years old or older.

DantesDame 17.12.2017 09:41

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Just see it, there are people who don't like it, there are people who love it. Critics and reviews give it good grades. Only one way to find out if you like it.
Yes, this is really the only "right" answer.

"Opinions are like assholes: everyone has one and everyone else's stinks" :D

Rachel Moore 17.12.2017 10:52

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Daff (Post 2886656)
Oh no! My husband and I drew straws on which one of us was going to take our 11 year old. I drew the short straw. Now I'm looking forward to it even less *sigh*. The things we do for our kids ...

lol...true, but I'd happily swap sitting in a warm cinema with some goodies, than suffer 2.5 hours in dreich Scottish weather with horizontal rain penetrating 4 layers of clothing as you try and look happy watching your wee one play for his local footy team!

Rachel Moore 17.12.2017 11:00

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
If your 8 year old child plays fighting video games recommended for an older age group, like so many other 8 year olds, then I would imagine this movie will not shock.

olygirl 17.12.2017 12:04

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
I would normally advise anyone who wants to see the The Last Jedi to be swimming in the lethargic effects of too many alcoholic beverages but in the case of your 8-year old, I think explaining the story using puppets beforehand might be more appropriate.

A previous poster said "hot mess." I agree completely.

Speaking of... what was the deal with the

***SPOILER ALERT ***

iron?

EDIT

And what about the creepy scene of Luke milking an alien cow (who was completely enjoying the hands-on feeling) and then drinking the stuff? My God, that was not Jedi-like but just green-puking disgusting.

marchise 17.12.2017 12:30

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
I would be careful.....there are many nicer cartoon that are probably more suitable for a 8 yrs boy (and probably with a better message as well)

slammer 17.12.2017 14:16

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by olygirl (Post 2886839)
I would normally advise anyone who wants to see the The Last Jedi to be swimming in the lethargic effects of too many alcoholic beverages but in the case of your 8-year old, I think explaining the story using puppets beforehand might be more appropriate.

A previous poster said "hot mess." I agree completely.

Speaking of... what was the deal with the

***SPOILER ALERT ***

iron?

EDIT

And what about the creepy scene of Luke milking an alien cow (who was completely enjoying the hands-on feeling) and then drinking the stuff? My God, that was not Jedi-like but just green-puking disgusting.

It could only have been worst if they had added a zombie Jar Jar Binks, but then they had them puke saccharine cutey cute penguin things as comic relief. The original had some sublime comedy moments but this offering tried to be funny in a PC conform way making the "jokes" and I use the term flexible... strained! I struggled through J.J. Abrabinks Startrek beyond but I have never so very wanted a way to fast forward the cringey bits of The last Jedi, perhaps as Luke said the Jedi should die and so should the franchise. By the way what was with Yoda doing the funky chicken?

DantesDame 17.12.2017 19:16

Re: Star Wars movie for 8 y.o?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slammer (Post 2886870)
perhaps as Luke said the Jedi should die and so should the franchise.

There were just so many things wrong in this movie.

My husband, who is a die-hard Star Wars fan, kept giving me sidelong glances at some of the cringier scenes. And later he told me he just closed his eyes during some of the "boring" parts :msnshock:


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 18:25.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0