English Forum Switzerland

English Forum Switzerland (https://www.englishforum.ch/forum.php)
-   International affairs/politics (https://www.englishforum.ch/international-affairs-politics/)
-   -   Any Pastafarians here? (https://www.englishforum.ch/international-affairs-politics/119311-any-pastafarians-here.html)

summerrain 13.07.2011 19:03

Any Pastafarians here?
 
An Austrian atheist has won the right to be shown on his driving-licence photo wearing a pasta strainer as "religious headgear".

Mr Alm said the sieve was a requirement of his religion, pastafarianism. A self-confessed atheist, Mr Alm says he belongs to the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, a light-hearted faith whose members call themselves pastafarians.

Sounds like a yummy religion. I'm in!!! :D

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-14135523

Guest 13.07.2011 19:04

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Genius!! :D I'm in!!!!

Guest 13.07.2011 19:08

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Mr Alm's pastafarian-style application for a driving licence was a response to the Austrian recognition of confessional headgear in official photographs.
His point being... what, exactly? :confused:

SamWeiseVielleicht 13.07.2011 19:12

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
May you be touched by his noodly appendage, ramen.

poptart 13.07.2011 19:21

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
My old volvo back home had the usual fish with his noodly self inside. I refrain from straining my head through a pasta strainer, though. :) Awesome license/ID photo!

st2lemans 13.07.2011 19:37

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
In HIS honor, making pasta al ragu tonight, with durian ice-cream for a chaser!

Tom

Traubert 13.07.2011 19:53

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
I too have been touched by his noodly appendage. :rasta:

Doctor 13.07.2011 19:56

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
http://www.venganza.info/glaube.htm

"Unser Himmel ist weit besser: wir haben eine Stripperfabrik und einen Biervulkan."
translation: "Our Heaven is way better. We have a Stripper Factory and a Beer Volcano"

I convert immediately. First thing in the morning tomorrow, I go to the Gemeinde, but what should I tick re. Church Tax ?

Doc.

Guest 13.07.2011 20:04

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Where Pastafarianism has its sights aimed at the excesses of Christianity, I think it's a wonderful movement. The way they are protesting against the Creationist movement in the United States is, quite simply, brilliant.

This chap in Austria, though: at whom are his actions directed?

It all looks like fun and games, but it seems to me that there's something else going on here. How many Christian fundamentalists, after all, wear "confessional headgear" in their driving licence photographs?

To me, this looks like a very subtle, but nonetheless thoroughly illiberal, poke at the Muslims. Again. Because nobody else in Europe has thought to do that recently. :rolleyes:

st2lemans 13.07.2011 20:08

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

This chap in Austria, though: at whom are his actions directed?
At the government, obviously, as they allow some people to wear hats in photos, and others not. THIS is discrimination!

Tom

MathNut 13.07.2011 20:10

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Where Pastafarianism has its sights aimed at the excesses of Christianity, I think it's a wonderful movement. The way they are protesting against the Creationist movement in the United States is, quite simply, brilliant.

This chap in Austria, though: at whom are his actions directed?

It all looks like fun and games, but it seems to me that there's something else going on here. How many Christian fundamentalists, after all, wear "confessional headgear" in their driving licence photographs?

To me, this looks like a very subtle, but nonetheless thoroughly illiberal, poke at the Muslims. Again. Because nobody else in Europe has thought to do that recently. :rolleyes:
So it's brilliant to have a lighthearted movement poking fun at Christian fundamentalists - after all they believe some pretty absurd stuff and can be annoying about it - but Muslim fundamentalists (who incidentally tend to be creationists too ;)) are not fair game for the same treatment? Sorry, don't follow you.


They're both minorities within their respective religions, let alone the US/Austria at large. Why is it OK to make noodly fun of one but not the other?

Equal opportunity ridicule for all, I say.

Guest 13.07.2011 20:11

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by st2lemans (Post 1263503)
At the government, obviously, as they allow some people to wear hats in photos, and others not. THIS is discrimination!

Tom

True. But who is actually affected by such discrimination? Are the feelings of the baseball cap wearing youth of Vienna really hurt by allowing some women to wear headscarves while they must remove their caps?

On the other hand, who would be affected by insisting upon strictly equal treatment for all?

Guest 13.07.2011 20:13

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MathNut (Post 1263508)
So it's brilliant to have a lighthearted movement poking fun at Christian fundamentalists, but Muslim fundamentalists (who incidentally tend to be creationists too ;)) are not fair game for the same treatment? Sorry, don't follow you.


They're both minorities within their respective religions, let alone the US/Austria at large. Why is it OK to make noodly fun of one but not the other?

Because Christians in Europe - minority though they may be in many places - are not in any real danger of facing the kind of discrimination which is now becoming commonplace for Muslims.

I don't recall any nuns getting into hot water for insisting on wearing their wimples and cowls in public places recently.

Going for Muslims just isn't sporting any more.

amaraya 13.07.2011 20:14

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
when i was in college a pastafarian were the kids who made magic spaghetti, if you know what i mean ;)

Guest 13.07.2011 20:17

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MathNut (Post 1263508)
Equal opportunity ridicule for all, I say.

Unfortunately the moment you make fun of that other religion, there will be protests and burnings of flags etc etc...these of course manipulated :(

Guest 13.07.2011 20:19

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Angela-74 (Post 1263521)
Unfortunately the moment you make fun of that other religion, there will be protests and burnings of flags etc etc...these of course manipulated :(

I'd be curious to see if this young chap would have the balls to make direct fun of them. Much easier to take on the government of a nice, liberal democracy that has dared to accommodate the foibles some of its least loved citizens for once.

MrVertigo 13.07.2011 20:19

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
In honor of spaghetti bolognese we shall all eat our pasta facing not Mekka but Bologna.

MathNut 13.07.2011 20:20

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
This isn't discrimination though. This is making fun of the aspects of a religion - any religion - that outsiders find absurd. Either you think that sort of thing is in good taste or it isn't (and I mostly think it is, if done with a deft touch) - but one religion shouldn't be off-limits and the rest fair game, that's all I'm saying.

To turn your own argument back, who is being harmed by this guy's pasta-strainer driver's license? Muslims? Really?

Guest 13.07.2011 20:24

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MathNut (Post 1263527)
This isn't discrimination though. This is making fun of the aspects of a religion - any religion - that outsiders find absurd. Either you think that sort of thing is in good taste or it isn't (and I mostly think it is, if done with a deft touch) - but one religion shouldn't be off-limits and the rest fair game, that's all I'm saying.

Context - as always - is everything.

Take on the Muslims on their own territory? Go for it!

Take them on where they are a much-maligned minority? It's hardly sporting, is it?

Quote:

To turn your own argument back, who is being harmed by this guy's pasta-strainer driver's license? Muslims? Really?
At the moment, nobody. But then what happens when the Austrian driving authority gets dozens upon dozens of requests from people wanting to wear daft things on their heads and the rule - which is currently quite fair and accommodating - is changed so that nobody can wear "confessional headgear"? Because let's not be fooled here: this is exactly what the long term objective of such hilarity is.

MrVertigo 13.07.2011 20:25

Re: Any Pastafarians here?
 
actually I see that in a few decades christianism will be perceived as a parody of pastafarianism. Very often a very clever parody, and it's the case here, transcends what it's supposed to make fun of.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 13:23.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0