View Poll Results: What would you personally prefer to happen? |
I want the UK to stay in an ever-closer union
|    | 49 | 23.11% |
I want the UK to stay in a loosely connected EU
|    | 68 | 32.08% |
I want the UK out because the EU is bad for the UK
|    | 22 | 10.38% |
I want the UK out because the EU is a bad thing
|    | 23 | 10.85% |
I want the UK out because this would be good for the rest of us
|    | 17 | 8.02% |
I don't really care
|    | 33 | 15.57% |  | | | 
26.06.2016, 23:52
| Forum Veteran | | Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Vaud
Posts: 2,433
Groaned at 171 Times in 119 Posts
Thanked 4,818 Times in 1,862 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | An MP's job is to implement the will of the people of his electorate. That's Blueangel's point. In many constituencies, Remain won overall. Are the representatives of those constituencies (MPs) to uphold the will of their voters by voting against Brexit (if indeed they are to be given a vote, and this is the crux of the Scottish threat to annul the referendum result)?
No, he isn't. As explained above, MPs in the UK represent their own constituencies. | | | | | This is not an election though. It is a referendum. It is not first past the post. The regions are counted to sum up the numbers separately but the overall figure is the only one that counts. On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently.
| The following 5 users would like to thank Mikers for this useful post: | | 
26.06.2016, 23:55
|  | Member | | Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: ZuriOberland, CH
Posts: 196
Groaned at 14 Times in 7 Posts
Thanked 170 Times in 79 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This is not an election though. It is a referendum. It is not first past the post. The regions are counted to sum up the numbers separately but the overall figure is the only one that counts. On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently. | | | | | That is absolutely correct....top marks. | 
26.06.2016, 23:58
| Forum Legend | | Join Date: Mar 2013 Location: Formerly in Neuchatel
Posts: 2,964
Groaned at 231 Times in 158 Posts
Thanked 5,592 Times in 2,081 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This is not an election though. It is a referendum. It is not first past the post. The regions are counted to sum up the numbers separately but the overall figure is the only one that counts. On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently. | | | | | The referendum isn't legally binding so no.
They probably should though.
| The following 3 users would like to thank porsch1909 for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 00:01
|  | Member | | Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: ZuriOberland, CH
Posts: 196
Groaned at 14 Times in 7 Posts
Thanked 170 Times in 79 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | I (and many others) am terribly sad about the Poland-Switzerland match yesterday. The teams scored a goal each during the first 90 minutes, didn't score any during the extra time, and eventually Poland won by scoring 5 via the penalty shootout (as opposed to Switzerland's 4).
I insist on a rematch as (1) the margins are very narrow (just one missed out penalty shot!), (2) this is not the result I want, and (3) Xhaka wasn't aware of what was at stake and would have performed differently if he had complete information. | | | | | Excellent...I have copied this ( hope you don't mind) to post to my FB friends who are constantly whinging. | 
27.06.2016, 00:14
|  | Only in moderation | | Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Basel-Land
Posts: 8,994
Groaned at 283 Times in 224 Posts
Thanked 18,970 Times in 7,511 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This is not an election though. It is a referendum. It is not first past the post. The regions are counted to sum up the numbers separately but the overall figure is the only one that counts. On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently. | | | | | Yes, it's a national vote (and actually, it IS first past the post -- there is no purer form than a simple binary contest like this), but there are two points: it's not legally binding (as I've said half a dozen times), which allows MPs to consider whether they want to represent their electorates or not. That's all.
I can well see a number of politicians in London, Scotland and Northern Ireland with an eye on a looming P45 voting against Brexit.
| The following 2 users would like to thank 22 yards for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 00:59
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | | | | | | Funny how that is phrased. The EU has no choice until the UK is ready to invoke Article 50, and the political crisis is in the EU, not merely in the UK.
They even have people believing the EU = Europe.  A country cannot leave Europe, and the EU is merely a chain of offices with office workers.
| The following 3 users would like to thank for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:04
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Kt. Bern
Posts: 4,211
Groaned at 199 Times in 156 Posts
Thanked 6,722 Times in 3,028 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently. | | | | | Not so, in the UK the parliament is sovereign, not the people. Therefore there is no mechanism to force the parliament to comply with a referendum. You can fully expect the SNP will almost certainly vote against any exit legislation introduced in the coming months....
| The following 2 users would like to thank Jim2007 for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:08
|  | RIP | | Join Date: Oct 2011 Location: Murten - Morat
Posts: 11,885
Groaned at 563 Times in 354 Posts
Thanked 11,548 Times in 5,941 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in
I read the House of Parliament could forbid the Prime Minister to actuate clause 50. That would be an upset, and the MPs could then discuss whether to go ahead or not, with clause 50 in October.
| 
27.06.2016, 01:27
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Kt. Bern
Posts: 4,211
Groaned at 199 Times in 156 Posts
Thanked 6,722 Times in 3,028 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | I'm just amazed how unaccepting people are of a democratic outcome. You sound like someone running an African banana republic, not part of a functioning democracy. | | | | | Your functioning democracy has:
- An unelected head of state
- An unelected upper house
- A sovereign parliament
- No written constitution
- No constitutional court or similar function
- Referenda that cannot be binding on a sovereign parliament
The result is that PMs are primarily obliged to represent their constituents not the national interest.
| The following 3 users would like to thank Jim2007 for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:32
|  | Member | | Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: ZuriOberland, CH
Posts: 196
Groaned at 14 Times in 7 Posts
Thanked 170 Times in 79 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | Your functioning democracy has:
- An unelected head of state So What? - An unelected upper house Agree, that's dodgy
- A sovereign parliament Yep - No written constitution [I] So What?[/I]
- No constitutional court or similar function And? - Referenda that cannot be binding on a sovereign parliament But will be.
| | | | | And still the oldest parliament and the model for many around the world....not perfect, but not bad either.
| This user would like to thank Stoker177 for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:39
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Kt. Bern
Posts: 4,211
Groaned at 199 Times in 156 Posts
Thanked 6,722 Times in 3,028 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | |
And still the oldest parliament and the model for many around the world....not perfect, but not bad either.
| | | | | True, but in Ireland we made two important changes, ironically enough insisted upon by the British side during the treaty negotiations in 1922 - a written constitution and a sovereign people.
| The following 2 users would like to thank Jim2007 for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:44
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: May 2008 Location: Kt. Zürich
Posts: 9,747
Groaned at 430 Times in 371 Posts
Thanked 17,811 Times in 9,510 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | Who cares about the bloody poster?! This referendum wasn't won and lost on a poster. | | | | | Thank you for so politely avoiding the question.
The message I receive from your answer is that the end justifies the means; so it is OK to lie, cheat and give false information so long as at the end of the day we get the vote that we want.
| This user would like to thank marton for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:49
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: May 2008 Location: Kt. Zürich
Posts: 9,747
Groaned at 430 Times in 371 Posts
Thanked 17,811 Times in 9,510 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This, and the fact that the normal decent thing in a democracy is that when you lose a vote is that you lick your wounds, try and learn from your mistakes, but above all concede defeat and live with the result.
Cameron did the only honourable thing. A pity that others don't get that.
Try and learn from the Swiss. Outside of the EF, have you heard many people banging on about minarets lately, or preventing the second Gotthard road tunnel, or the 12:1 initiative? Neither have I. | | | | | "Outside of the EF, have you heard many people banging on about minarets lately, or preventing the second Gotthard road tunnel, or the 12:1 initiative? Neither have I."
Maybe if the Swiss proposing these initiatives would have made so many bare faced lies there would have been a different reaction, or not?
| The following 2 users would like to thank marton for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 01:52
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: May 2008 Location: Kt. Zürich
Posts: 9,747
Groaned at 430 Times in 371 Posts
Thanked 17,811 Times in 9,510 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This, and the fact that the normal decent thing in a democracy is that when you lose a vote is that you lick your wounds, try and learn from your mistakes, but above all concede defeat and live with the result.
Cameron did the only honourable thing. A pity that others don't get that.
Try and learn from the Swiss. Outside of the EF, have you heard many people banging on about minarets lately, or preventing the second Gotthard road tunnel, or the 12:1 initiative? Neither have I. | | | | | "the normal decent thing in a democracy" is that the political parties involved do not lie through their teeth; when they do then you can expect a reaction - not that such a reaction will achieve much here | 
27.06.2016, 02:08
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: May 2008 Location: Kt. Zürich
Posts: 9,747
Groaned at 430 Times in 371 Posts
Thanked 17,811 Times in 9,510 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | It doesn't matter. I can't say it enough times. If your mp can't face doing his job description which is to implement the will of the people then he should retire and have a by election. This whole mini argument is a pathetic waste of time. Doesn't matter if the country is going to walk off a cliff, it was a national referendum, not a local one and Leave won. For a national referendum he is now obliged to implement the will of the nation. Christ, is there anything that Remain won't try to bend the result? | | | | | An MP is responsible to implement the will of his constituents; not the will of the nation
Quote "MPs work in Parliament on behalf of all the people in their constituency" Source
Implementing the result of national referendums is a Government responsibility not individual MPs.
| 
27.06.2016, 02:19
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: May 2008 Location: Kt. Zürich
Posts: 9,747
Groaned at 430 Times in 371 Posts
Thanked 17,811 Times in 9,510 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | This is not an election though. It is a referendum. It is not first past the post. The regions are counted to sum up the numbers separately but the overall figure is the only one that counts. On this topic it is a national referendum so the mp must adhere to the national will of the people. If they wanted it locally, then it should have been set up differently. | | | | | Quote "MPs work in Parliament on behalf of all the people in their constituency"
Implementing the result of national referendums is a Government responsibility not individual MPs.
Inventing new responsibilities for MPs (e.g. the mp must adhere to the national will of the people) does not take us forward and is actually nonsense  .
An MP works in Parliament on behalf of all the people in their constituency.
Where, for example, they are part of a minority party they are not obliged to follow "the national will of the people" who voted in a majority of another party.
| 
27.06.2016, 02:24
|  | à la mod | | Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: ZG
Posts: 5,420
Groaned at 113 Times in 91 Posts
Thanked 16,138 Times in 5,143 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | Yes, it's a national vote (and actually, it IS first past the post -- there is no purer form than a simple binary contest like this) | | | | | And yet the Americans wouldn't have been mad enough to have had such a reckless contest. Amendments to the Constitution, especially those with entrenched clauses commonly require a supermajority (e.g. two thirds) support in a legislature.
| The following 5 users would like to thank Castro for this useful post: | | 
27.06.2016, 07:30
| Forum Veteran | | Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Vaud
Posts: 2,433
Groaned at 171 Times in 119 Posts
Thanked 4,818 Times in 1,862 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | Not so, in the UK the parliament is sovereign, not the people. Therefore there is no mechanism to force the parliament to comply with a referendum. You can fully expect the SNP will almost certainly vote against any exit legislation introduced in the coming months.... | | | | | I'm not saying it's legally binding Jim I agree it's down to the mp, I was responding to the earlier point by blueangel which said it was. I still firmly believe that if parliament went against the will of the people it would be catastrophic for the country.
| 
27.06.2016, 07:45
|  | Forum Legend | | Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Democratic Republic Kenistan
Posts: 10,690
Groaned at 281 Times in 232 Posts
Thanked 19,403 Times in 7,402 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in
With a shortfall in the EU coffers once the UK has left - I wonder whether the Germans will bring this back to the table
Sure it was voted down 5 years ago but the game has moved on - and if they want a United States of Europe it would be a good start
| 
27.06.2016, 07:57
| Forum Veteran | | Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Vaud
Posts: 2,433
Groaned at 171 Times in 119 Posts
Thanked 4,818 Times in 1,862 Posts
| | Re: The Brexit referendum thread: potential consequences for GB, EU and the Brits in | Quote: | |  | | | Yes, it's a national vote (and actually, it IS first past the post -- there is no purer form than a simple binary contest like this), but there are two points: it's not legally binding (as I've said half a dozen times), which allows MPs to consider whether they want to represent their electorates or not. That's all.
I can well see a number of politicians in London, Scotland and Northern Ireland with an eye on a looming P45 voting against Brexit. | | | | | It's not first past the post locally, which was the point raised.
More talk today of second referendum, Scots may vote against, mp's calling result into question. I really fear for democracy in the uk right now.
|
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 6 (0 members and 6 guests) | | Thread Tools | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT +2. The time now is 22:59. | |