English Forum Switzerland

English Forum Switzerland (https://www.englishforum.ch/forum.php)
-   Transportation/driving (https://www.englishforum.ch/transportation-driving/)
-   -   Cost of installing charging units for electric cars? (https://www.englishforum.ch/transportation-driving/296792-cost-installing-charging-units-electric-cars.html)

meloncollie 17.02.2020 19:24

Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Might I call on the wisdom/experience of the EF group mind here?

We will discuss installing charging systems for electric cars at our next Quartierversammlung. (Soooooo looking forward to another bunfight cost sharing discussion. :rolleyes: )

The proposal sent out shows the cost (upgrading wiring, basic installation, charging unit) to be about CHF 6K per parking spot, based on sharing the cost over a 50 parking space garage.

Those of you who have installed chargers at your homes or common garages, does this seem ballpark?

Many thanks.

fatmanfilms 17.02.2020 19:30

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by meloncollie (Post 3149127)
Might I call on the wisdom/experience of the EF group mind here?

We will discuss installing charging systems for electric cars at our next Quartierversammlung. (Soooooo looking forward to another bunfight cost sharing discussion. :rolleyes: )

The proposal sent out shows the cost (upgrading wiring, basic installation, charging unit) to be about CHF 6K per parking spot, based on sharing the cost over a 50 parking space garage.

Those of you who have installed chargers at your homes or common garages, does this seem ballpark?

Many thanks.

In Chamonix, France we have been quoted €800 per socket with a min of 10 sockets so you are being Switzerlanded.

Having installed 64amp 3 phase sockets in CH for filming, they cost about 1k each, obviously a long cable run could increase costs but not 6k a socket.

Guest 17.02.2020 19:32

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
In the UK you can apparently get an installed socket charging system thingy for around 300. So yes, Switzerlanded.

Edit: Ah, ok. Approx 1k but grants are being offered which reduces the cost to the 300 mark.

Still... 6k chuffs is much too much.

Surely the point of "bulk buying" is to reduce the per item cost?

Guest 17.02.2020 19:34

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Sounds like a lot, however we offc have no clue of the amount of time/work and materials needed.

Also you say "charging system" so I assume you get some more than just some socket.

Axa 17.02.2020 19:47

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by meloncollie (Post 3149127)
The proposal sent out shows the cost (upgrading wiring, basic installation, charging unit) to be about CHF 6K per parking spot, based on sharing the cost over a 50 parking space garage.

Being able to charge 50 cars? :eek: Maybe this is the cause. Being able to charge 2, 3 or 5 cars may be within the capacity of the current installation and just a minor amount of work is needed. Being able to charge lots of cars, implies rebuilding the whole thing. Ordering a lot may make the costs higher, instead of the expected savings for ordering lots of items.

fatmanfilms 17.02.2020 19:51

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Axa (Post 3149132)
Being able to charge 50 cars? :eek: Maybe this is the cause. Being able to charge 2, 3 or 5 cars may be within the capacity of the current installation and just a minor amount of work is needed. Being able to charge lots of cars, implies rebuilding the whole thing. Ordering a lot may make the costs higher, instead of the expected savings for ordering lots of items.

Even for 5 cars you will need another feed, it should be in the road so not that far in most cases to run a bigger cable.

doropfiz 17.02.2020 20:41

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Maybe this user could tell you about their experience with this:
https://www.englishforum.ch/daily-li...rking-lot.html

st2lemans 17.02.2020 21:20

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
I thought you lived in the boonies? Why do you have 50 parking spots? :confused:

Tom

meloncollie 17.02.2020 22:07

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by st2lemans (Post 3149163)
I thought you lived in the boonies? Why do you have 50 parking spots? :confused:

Tom

It's the Quartier underground garage, built circa late 80s. Even out in the (once) boonies (now ex-urbia) you can't fully escape collective living. The Quartier is a bunch of houses sharing a common garage. We each own a portion, thus collective decision making.

This thread is showing me how much I don't know about this whole topic. I know little about my own car, even less about electric cars, so going through this proposal is pretty much an exercise in WTFery.

Quote:


Also you say "charging system" so I assume you get some more than just some socket.
That was just my translation from 'Ladestation pro Parkplatz'. Cost for this bit is CHF 3800 if that sheds any light. What would you guess that means?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Axa (Post 3149132)
Being able to charge 50 cars? :eek: Maybe this is the cause.

Now I'm getting nervous. In my ignorance I just assumed we'd all get a plug-in thingamajig, plug our cars in as and when, and go on about our lives. But good point about capacity. I'm suddenly getting a horror vision of something akin to a charging rota... :eek:


So... let's turn this thread around. Given my complete lack of understanding of the subject, what questions should I be asking at the Quartierversammlung?

Guest 17.02.2020 22:29

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by meloncollie (Post 3149173)
So... let's turn this thread around. Given my complete lack of understanding of the subject, what questions should I be asking at the Quartierversammlung?

- What exact Ladestation you'll get.
- Maximum charging capacity for your car.
- Maximum charging capacity for the whole installation. Not that it starts "choking" when 15 people are loading at the same time"
- Are there batteries in the charging station, and what is their capacity.
- Warranty / Maintenance.
- How will usage be billed.

Phil_MCR 17.02.2020 22:38

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
how long would it take to charge a car using one of these: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000...archweb201603_

Guest 17.02.2020 23:00

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil_MCR (Post 3149184)
how long would it take to charge a car using one of these: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000...archweb201603_

20 hours for the LRP

AbFab 17.02.2020 23:44

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
I can only advise in relation to a Tesla Model 3.

Maximum rate of charge A/C (alternating current) of a Tesla is 11kWh. It is almost certain that the system you are considering will be A/C. D/C is much faster and more expensive to install. Ionity and Tesla Superchargers are DC and charge at rates of 130kWh and more.

My Tesla Wall Connector (not charger, the charger is in the car) cost CHF500 and the installation to our garage through existing channeling of a 3-phase supply from cellar to an external garage about 4 metres away. Including, mounting the unit etc was an additional CHF1900. So CHF2400.-.

11kWh adds 65kms per hour of charging. A public charging point is likely to be less than this. Maybe 6 or 8kWh. Though at 6K a pop they really should be faster.

Also will charging be free and will the bays be exclusive to electric vehicles?

I'm very encouraged that communities are thinking this way. It's the future!

AbFab 17.02.2020 23:46

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil_MCR (Post 3149184)
how long would it take to charge a car using one of these: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000...archweb201603_

Teslas come with a similar connector for the normal 220 volt mains. They charge at about 6kms added per hour...

Guest 18.02.2020 00:44

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbFab (Post 3149194)
Also will charging be free and will the bays be exclusive to electric vehicles?

How would one achieve free charging if one installs a charging station in ones own parking garage?

AbFab 18.02.2020 07:26

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

How would one achieve free charging if one installs a charging station in ones own parking garage?
There are (sadly at the moment) dozens of organizations that charge per minute or per kWh for using a charger. Our local Migros has 2 bays run by Swisscharge, which cost and need a Swisscharge card to operate.

Meanwhile, our local garden centre has 2 free charging bays.

So a parking garage could charge and defray the costs or be free and foot the bill for installing, electricity and maintenance. Either way, 6K per bay is over the top...

TonyClifton 18.02.2020 07:47

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
If one is a home owner, would installation of a charging unit be considered tax deductible?

st2lemans 18.02.2020 08:19

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbFab (Post 3149194)
will charging be free?

Why should it be, unless they make electricity free?

Tom

meloncollie 18.02.2020 09:36

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Good questions re: ongoing charging costs/ individual metering of electric use

Currently the electricity cost for the garage is split among the owners, each pays based on the number of parking spots one owns. Only a few will likely rush out and buy an electric car once charging stations are installed, making for unequal usage in the short to medium term.

So I foresee yet another kerfuffle at the Quartier meeting, any proposal that hints that someone might end up paying for something not benefitting them while benefitting another usually devolves into the mother of all bunfights...

Those who have electric cars - can you give me an idea of what your additional electric costs due to charging have been?

Also interesting question about tax deductions. Are there incentives? And if so I wonder who could/should apply for them, each individual owner, or the garage Genossenschaft? The latter is still the owners, but an interesting financial question.



Lawdy, I am not looking forward to this Quartier meeting...

st2lemans 18.02.2020 09:45

Re: Cost of installing charging units for electric cars?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbFab (Post 3149194)
Maximum rate of charge A/C (alternating current) of a Tesla is 11kWh.

kW, NOT kWh!

kWh is the charge, not the charge rate.

Anyway, 11kW is 50A. 50A x 50chargers = 2500A! :eek:

(2500/3 = 833A if 3P charging)

You will need your own substation for that!

Tom


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 02:50.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0